• Biblical Families is not a dating website. It is a forum to discuss issues relating to marriage and the Bible, and to offer guidance and support, not to find a wife. Click here for more information.

So eventually I might get excommunicated in a few years

So some time ago I asked the Pastor what he would do if I married more than one woman and he said, he might excommunicate me because he believes it is adultery

He said he can not prove it is adultery but you can not prove it is not, and that has been the stance of the Church fathers.

[Of course I have never heard of the great Southern Baptist Church Fathers, (by the way I am not Southern Baptist ;) ), he has never ever explained to me where this denomination comes from, but.... he said it is important to him to have a denomination so he picked this one because it is "the most Biblical." Southern Baptists could very well have "great Church Fathers" but... they just never taught me about them]

I could give numerous reasons why I think people there proclaim polygyny is wrong on an emotional basis but I will not go there.

So what should I do considering sooner or later I will have to leave essentially any Church I join?

And if polygyny is so bad shouldn't he kick me out for being a false teaching heretic who disagrees with everyone (I do not bring up the topic much anymore because I explained my point of view and saw they are not accepting of the truth and that is enough.)
 
I have grown up Southern Baptist and have never hear of these "church fathers" you speak of....

However, OUR pastor read my blog a few months back and asked my DH if we are considering PM... He was a little worried but our pastor asked that we at least let him pray with us about it. He agreed that it is not a sin nor adultery and he wanted to pray with us and for us.

It sounds to me like your pastor is MONO minded and not truly searching scripture for the answers.
 
Join the Church ?!?!?!?!?!

DiscussingTheTopic said:
He said he can not prove it is adultery but you can not prove it is not, and that has been the stance of the Church fathers.
[Of course I have never heard of the great Southern Baptist Church Fathers, (by the way I am not Southern Baptist ;) ),

He is referring to the Pre/Post Nicene Church fathers. This is the voice of the church past (one of the areas we get theology from). Historically what has the CHURCH (All believers at all places at all times) accepted. Remember we all view the scriptures through lenses, not clear, that color our view and understanding of the BIble.

you should have heard of the So. Baptist Church Fathers. They are the ones who broke from northern baptists over slavery.

DiscussingTheTopic said:
I could give numerous reasons why I think people there proclaim polygyny is wrong on an emotional basis but I will not go there.

This seems to be the only answer people give in rebuttal. I have talked, water cooler talk, with several people about PM. One woman said she was to greedy to have a sister wife.

DiscussingTheTopic said:
So what should I do considering sooner or later I will have to leave essentially any Church I join?

Why should you 'join' a church? The few times we have 'joined' a church people were shocked we were not official members. We give money, time, resources and effort to the local church. Where does the NT say anything about 'joining' a church. People were added as believers but did not 'join' a local church. And if you join a church why do you pass 5 others on the way there on Sunday AM?

ALSO what do you get out of being a member on the rolls of a church???? A chance to vote in the yearly meeting? Vote on a pastor? Why should we vote on any of these things? The argument is much easier made that these are wrong to do and NOT biblical. For the record I have never voted on anything in a church, including when it would benefit me personally.

Stoopidst thing that I ever had to do in my life: I was the pastor of a church and had to become a member. :o People got upset because I (and my family) did not 'join' the church as a member. Yes you read that right. I did not know I had to 'join' the church. Here I am working and serving and doing all the things pastors do: hospital, evangelizing, growing the church, had first baptisms there in 10 years, bury, marry, sermonize, visit and everything else and some (one?) people were upset because I did not join the church. Oh yeah this happened a year after I was there. So we had it arranged on how to handle it and I doubt I have ever been more embarrassed :oops: in church then I was for those 10 minutes.
 
I do not mean join as in get an official membership. I mean spend a good deal of my time with a specific group of people who proclaim to be Christians.

And also possibly continue to give some money. It is better than giving my money directly to the "poor" in my experience.

The Pastor and Church body I go to is more wise in helping truly need people with money than me. I have found that I have accidentally given my money to lazy "poor" people and deeply regretted it because I should have given it to the needy poor people.

I wish I donated that money to one of two church organizations I can think of instead. Or possibly to one of those anti-abortion groups or groups to help needy poor overseas instead of lazy poor in the U.S.
 
So like they do not really believe these Church fathers they are quoting do they?

What was the whole protestant movement about anyway?

What about that Sola Scriptura stuff they claim to believe? (By the way if I believed in Scripture alone, I could not use a bus map to get to work/school, etc, or for that matter even know how to eat a bowl of cereal , or for that matter know how to read to even read scripture) :lol:
 
Sometimes I wonder if I should even "attend Church" if people are just going to have such bad interpretations of the Bible.

But I think it keeps me from a bad bad path I saw many people go on. But seriously other Church members might pull me down to bad behavior.

I need someone to keep me accountable but, they can not keep me accountable to my moral principles in any areas regarding women, because..... I have a different set of principles and am still trying to form my principles with no one who also believes in BIBLICAL polygyny (including Biblical purity) to guide me locally.

and ugh..... form a friendship with someone and tell them your deep struggles and things that you do not normally tell everyone so they can keep you accountable, who will inevitably excommunicate you :roll:

Spend so many years developing friendships with church members who will then kick you out :roll:

Try to develop friendship with people who you are unequally yoked with who are Christian unbelievers :roll:

Makes more sense to just develop friendships with those labeled as non-Christians who share similar values then those labeled as christians who have backwards values.

But who knows they could be Christians, it just is sometimes it seems like they are not Christians anywhere where I live, so why "bother going to church"
 
Nikismom said:
I have grown up Southern Baptist and have never hear of these "church fathers" you speak of....

However, OUR pastor read my blog a few months back and asked my DH if we are considering PM... He was a little worried but our pastor asked that we at least let him pray with us about it. He agreed that it is not a sin nor adultery and he wanted to pray with us and for us.

It sounds to me like your pastor is MONO minded and not truly searching scripture for the answers.

Do you think if I keep searching around I can find a more open minded to truth (yet intolerant of sin) congregation and Pastor?

InterVarsity say they are interdenonimational I could test that statement ;) Do you think they would snitch on me to my previous Pastor from years ago? They snitched on me before for other things (that were not unethical but just different) and I got long surprise lectures from my Pastor several years ago :shock:

Yeah, don't tell intervarsity other Churches you've been to or you will regret it later when they snitch on you for different beliefs and give your Pastor a call.

The ironic thing is the Pastor believed in the same thing :o that he gave me a scolding for mentioning. But that is a long story and I do not want to misrepresent or gossip.

I can predict the results

"Hello you say you are interdenominational do you accept my denomination of one member? " :lol:

"No it has to be major denomination or at least fit in our imaginary god box so we can be people pleasers, and stay consistent with the god we imagined"
 
DiscussingTheTopic said:
So like they do not really believe these Church fathers they are quoting do they?

What was the whole protestant movement about anyway?

What about that Sola Scriptura stuff they claim to believe? (By the way if I believed in Scripture alone, I could not use a bus map to get to work/school, etc, or for that matter even know how to eat a bowl of cereal , or for that matter know how to read to even read scripture) :lol:

For the most part they believe the Church Fathers when they agree with the point they are making.

One of the greatest unknown problems we have is that Christen theology changes and changes rather harshly. For about 70% of the stuff 'we' believe in as the church (American for sure) would be considered heresy. Read the stuff about Marcion the Heretic, he would feel mostly at home in today's American Church (yes there would be some severe areas of disagreement). The main reasons he received label Heretic would apply to most American Christians today.

Another big change is the pre-trib rapture. That came from a dream a woman had in the 1870s.

The voice of the Church Past has something to day today. The question is weight of authority, in regards to Protestant reformation.

I think I gained some wisdom from you: Are you saying that Malachi is does NOT have a pancake recipe in it? That might explain my pancake issues.
 
macike said:
DiscussingTheTopic said:
I think I gained some wisdom from you: Are you saying that Malachi is does NOT have a pancake recipe in it? That might explain my pancake issues.

Yes that would be one of many examples. :D

Furthermore Malachi does not teach you the Hebrew language so you can understand how to read Malachi.
 
Seriously should I quit "going to Church"

or

look for another Church.

I do not think I well find one, it is kind of like voting, where you just do not get a candidate to represent your beliefs (unless you are brainwashed or very lucky)
 
The early church fathers for the baptists would have to be the Munzterite Anabaptists, and they were polygamous, so there.

Actually, that IS where most of the things Mackie complained about came from. Voting on leadership was high on the rebel list of grievances and the membership system and core elements of Baptist specific theology developed out of the Anabaptist. They would typically only credit the later, non-polygamous Anabaptist's for these developments though. Still, the Southern Baptist militancy definitely comes from the early peasant revolt Anabaptists and not the later pacifist Anabaptists.
 
DiscussingTheTopic said:
Seriously should I quit "going to Church"

or

look for another Church.

I do not think I well find one, it is kind of like voting, where you just do not get a candidate to represent your beliefs (unless you are brainwashed or very lucky)


Oops a little but old for the reply. Ihave stopped going to church. My frustrations are so high. I was a pastor for several years, taught bible a christian school and my frustrations with the 'christian community' is high. I have little tolerance anymore for stupidity. I have lots for people who want to learn and know.

I want to know and learn. CHurch does not seem to be the place for that.
 
We successfully gave up on church long ago. We still talk about 'trying it one more time', but ever time we give in (about every other year or so), it's a monumental disappointment. Mostly we joke about it now.
 
A Sad Commentary On The Church

donnag said:
We successfully gave up on church long ago. We still talk about 'trying it one more time', but ever time we give in (about every other year or so), it's a monumental disappointment. Mostly we joke about it now.

Ya know, I am in the same situation, I find the line to be sad . . . sad for the church.
What does it say when so many people (over a rather large area) cannot find a church with the 1000s that are out there. I live in a town of bout 20K people there re 33 churches in a 3 mile radius (or less) from my house, two in easy walking distance. Where I used to live in MN (town of 2000 people) there were nearly 20 churches. We drove 1.5 hours from a Messianic Congregation. Think of all the churches we passed. Why do we pass on all these places . . . that is a really good question.

I am an ex pastor, ex messianic rabbi, and I want nothing to do with church. For the record I 'preach' the gospel far better where I work and I "Preach the Gospel always, and if necessary, use words." Oh yeah . . . I am often asked what makes me different.
 
The last church I regularly attended was Calvary Chapel. I started hearing things like "I don't think God really hated Esau" and "God created Jesus". When I confronted the pastors saying these things with verses from the scriptures they went straight to "Well I think" at which point I smiled and stated "I'm actually not that interested in your opinion since it contradicts the Word of God." At this point they became defensive and accused me of being deceived. There were a number of other points of contention I raised to no avail. I try to keep what Jesus said in mind:

Matthew 18:20 For where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I among them."

I consider "church" the gathering of the brethren, and where two or more are gathered in His name there is church also. I have realized that trying to follow the doctrines of specific denominations is virtually impossible because I have heard a number of errors in the teachings of all of them. Reading the scriptures, following the leading of the Holy Spirit, praying, and enjoying the fellowship of other believers has brought me into a much closer relationship with the lord than sitting in a pew and listening to someone tell me what and how I should believe ever could.
 
I realize that not every believer has had a positive church experience...but I just want to say that I really appreciate my church. It's not perfect (I've never been to one that was) but there is a very real sense of love and caring to be found there. I've been to other churches through the years and they've all taught me a great deal. I honestly wouldn't be where I am today without them. I consider their influence upon my Spiritual walk to be irreplaceable. I am also being courted by a senior pastor and I have been so impressed with the level of concern and compassion that I've seen him extend to his congregation. IMHO, we need to be praying for and supporting the men whom the Lord has called to shepherd His flock....just my opinion :)

Blessings,
Fairlight
 
Fairlight said:
I realize that not every believer has had a positive church experience...but I just want to say that I really appreciate my church. It's not perfect (I've never been to one that was) but there is a very real sense of love and caring to be found there. I've been to other churches through the years and they've all taught me a great deal. I honestly wouldn't be where I am today without them. I consider their influence upon my Spiritual walk to be irreplaceable. I am also being courted by a senior pastor and I have been so impressed with the level of concern and compassion that I've seen him extend to his congregation. IMHO, we need to be praying for and supporting the men whom the Lord has called to shepherd His flock....just my opinion :)

Blessings,
Fairlight

There is a common theme of people who are hurt by pastors and churches among this community. It is one reason why so many start off with a skpetical and critical spirit towards those in leadership or towards those with academic training or even those who are, or have been, pastors. Since their hearts are injured they speak from that wound that has yet to be healed by grace and forgiveness.

It is a real struggle for those who have come to see this view of Scripture and then have been mistreated, thrown out, or rejected. Sometimes though some have been kicked out because of their attitude and lack of patience with leaders who were still needing to learn as well. At other times even when those with the right understanding were patient they were still rudely and unloving treated.

Yet, there is a day developing where a new breed and men and women are arising who are going to love their enemies, respect all people even the ones whom they disagree with, and who will avoid allowing bittnerness to control them so they can still fulfill the Great Commission.

There are believers now developing who see this issue not as an obstacle but as an opportunity for the gospel to shine bright in a new day where many need a new, fresh, and powerful dose of the gospel from a new movement that truly understands love, grace, and the idea of family. About 78 million to be exact are in this category now. They are called the Millennial Generation and they are ripe for a message of love from the lips of a hopeful person not a critical and complaining person.

Normally the first generation or so of a new movement experiences anger, frustration, and they lash out and go on the attack. Sometimes it is ugly, and yes sometimes it is disrespectful. Yet at times some get it right and the effort is holy and balanced. It varies.

But then after about a generation or so this the people, and the children of that generation, begin to see that there needs to be organization for power to be maximized and properly channeled. These people then begin to see again the value, the need, and the blessing of forming local churches or missionary organizations to help go forth to build disciples for the Great Commission.

Like with all things it is a pendulum swing.

I'll share a couple of verses here that apply:

"Strive for peace with everyone, and for the holiness without which no one will see the Lord. See to it that no fails to obtain the grace of God; that no root of bitterness springs up and causes trouble, and by it many are defiled" (Heb. 12:14-15)

"Bless those who persecute you; bless and do not curse them. . . . If possible, so far as it depends on you, live peaceably with all. Beloved never avenge yourselves, but leave it to the wrath of God, for it is written, Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord. To the contrary, if your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him something to drink; for by doing so you will heap burning coals on his head. Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good" (Rom. 12:14,18-21).

"Do all things wqithout grumbling or questioning [a skeptical/hypercritical spirit attitude], that you may be blameless and innocent, children of God without blemish in the midst of a crooked and twisted generation, among whom you shine as lights in the world" (Phil. 2:14-15).

One of the reasons some do not shine as lights in the midst of the areas and churches where the theology is in error is because instead of showing grace, gentleness, and patience those who have the truth show anger, bitterness, and disrespect. We sometimes who have the truth are our worse enemies. We sometimes destroy ourselves and our message by the way we conduct ourselves with the truth.

If you are without a church home I suggest instead of complaining about your local churches and leaders that you begin to do things to bless them. Invite the local pastors over to dinner and do not discuss polygyny but just pray for them and with them for the stress they are under. After and in time when you have built a relationship with the person the discussion will come naturally as you fellowship in the Lord. Do you know how many pastors have no true friend? They hear complaints, arguments, gossip, and ugly words towards them every day for years upon years. This damages their spirits too and they are wounded and in need of true friends in the Lord.

If you hunt call one up and go hunting with him. If you fish take one along with you to fish and build a friendship. Sure, he may try and evangelize you. Take it in stride and talk about the faith you have in Christ. When he asks why you don't attend his church, and he will because if he sees you as a friend he wants more friends there since he already has so many who complain, grumble, and gripe already, share with him that you just have not yet found the right place because of some doctrines you hold to but that those can be discussed later. Keep building the friendship though and praying for him and with him for him to be used of God. In time God will open the door to discuss the doctrine of love and marriage. And guess what, by that time he will think you are one of the most mature people he has ever met and then the discussion will have more weight in his heart because he respects you because you have shown him love and respect for a period of time. He sees, feels, and knows you are not mean, crazy, Mormon, etc etc.

If someone loves them, truly loves them, and cares for their soul and ministers to them it can be fresh wind of air to them and it might even open their eyes to discuss and hear what the Bible has to say on other matters.

I have relationships with numerous pastors. Some who understand this, some who do not, and some who oppose it and yet i've been able to retain a respect, friendship, and cordial relationship with them even if I am not a part of their particular fellowship. I can and do go in and out visiting and attending and so far my friendships with them have remained solid even though we may not agree on this or even on other issues. I say that not to toot my horn. That is not the point. The point is these brothers are humans and they desire friendship and they, just like us, crave to be loved and respected.

We can get farther and do more by blessing them instead of cursing them. If we agree with 10 or 20 or 30 things they have right then we need to encourage them in those areas. When we are in the community we need to praise them in front of others for what they do have right aqnd for what they are doing right. In time if we do that and fulfill on our end the effort to make an attempt at living at peace with all people then God will bless the effort and he will open up a door for us to discuss other topics with them.

And, too, we don't have all things right in our theology either. As we do this we might hear something from them that we still need to hear as well and it might be something God is using them to teach us as we might have some error in us that they see and want to share with us.

The simple goal of love is truly not so simple because it requires humility and hard work on our end. It makes us put our pride down.

The doctrine of Polygyny is not and can never be the most essential aspect of who we are or we will never make progress. The gospel, which is fundamentally about loving our Lord and neighbor, must be our theme and as this subject arises then it can be discussed.

God is slowly raising up a set of believers who will do more work with the gospel, and who also believe this doctrine, but who are going to major on the gospel and allow God to by his own hand bring this up as the work of the gospel is being done. These believers are respectful of authority, even those in error, and they are seeking to build relationships and peace building bridges with those in error, like Christ did by coming to earth for us, and these believers are shining as they touch the lives of pastors and even church members who are hurting and need a touch of the love from the Holy Spirit. And in that process these believers are making inroads into the lives of others which leads them to desire to listen to this doctrine of love in a biblical union.

The means to victory is not through complaining, but through community. The means to progress is not through anarchy but through agape action. The means to gaining respect as a movement is not through denunciation of leaders and churches but through dialog and deliberation with them so they know you are for the cause of the gospel first and foremost.

In following that path success will come, not overnight but in due time. As the Bible says, there is "always faith, hope, and the greatest of these is love." Let us then live in that spirit of hope as we inspire others to hope for a better day.

The world has enough people who grumble, complain, and are disrespectful as it is. Let us be different, let us be the true lights that shine grace in the darkness!

Dr. Allen
 
It would be interesting to know how many of our fellow believers in Biblical Marriage have been given "the left foot of fellowship."

Such a poll might even include more detailed questions, such as how many times, whether the "left foot" was given for actually being married to more than one woman, or just for expressing the truth. It should include an option to change one's vote sometime down the road if a person's situation changes - a person might vote "never been booted out" today, but then tomorrow, get the "left foot" from the church they are part of. (Or vote "been booted once," then it happens again... :o )

I check the poll questions regularly to see what is happening in the "Biblical Marriage World," and if I see a new poll question, will participate.

(guess I should put this in my "sig" file rather than typing it every post!):
Dr. Marvin George
"PolyDoc"
 
Fairlight said:
I realize that not every believer has had a positive church experience...but I just want to say that I really appreciate my church. It's not perfect (I've never been to one that was) but there is a very real sense of love and caring to be found there. I've been to other churches through the years and they've all taught me a great deal. I honestly wouldn't be where I am today without them. I consider their influence upon my Spiritual walk to be irreplaceable. I am also being courted by a senior pastor and I have been so impressed with the level of concern and compassion that I've seen him extend to his congregation. IMHO, we need to be praying for and supporting the men whom the Lord has called to shepherd His flock....just my opinion :)

Blessings,
Fairlight


I am happy and glad that you have a good church.

I agree with impressions and learnings that I have received along the way has been good. However, since we left southern Calif, we have not found a church that has been worth going to, with one exception. The worst part is that I pastored two of them, they were both really old churches that oddly enough I would not have gone to unless I was the pastor. In restrospect they were mistakes.
 
Re: A Sad Commentary On The Church

macike said:
donnag said:
We successfully gave up on church long ago. We still talk about 'trying it one more time', but ever time we give in (about every other year or so), it's a monumental disappointment. Mostly we joke about it now.

Ya know, I am in the same situation, I find the line to be sad . . . sad for the church...

There is a reason why the Bible so often uses the metaphor of "whoring" to describe a "church" which denies Him and teaches rebellion to His Word. Those "pastors" or false shepherds who teach contrary to Him, perhaps because they care far more about their 501c(3) tax-exempt status than they do Him, already "have their reward".

The rest of us have learned to look elsewhere, and to "come out of her", so that we separate ourselves from the coming plagues. (Rev. 18:4) Meanwhile, we are tasked to warn that Remnant with "ears to hear", because we cannot help but see a "sword coming upon the land".
 
Back
Top